If you're reading this post, you probably know that I live-tweet many shows on Twitter on my account @TalkingTV. One of those shows is Top Chef. I'm not alone on Twitter when I do this; there's a bunch of other people who do the same thing and we all tend to riff together online during the show.
In November, I suggested to three of my fellow Twitterers, @sjcaustenite, @roadtohell, and @KatieHall that it would be fun if we all got together to watch an episode of Top Chef together. We're geographically close and I thought it would be a lot of fun. After some scheduling discussion, we all convened at @KatieHall's place for Episode 3.
I also had the "bright idea" to record us during the show so we could release it to the public. That way, everyone could hear our jokes since we weren't on Twitter during the show. So embedded below is the 1 hour recording of the four of us from the time the episode started until the credits rolled. We hope you like it. If you don't see the player below, you can download the file here: http://dl.dropbox.com/u/3254629/topchef8x03.mp3. If that link doesn't work, let me know at abonetopick@gmail.com and I'll try to fix it.
Tuesday, December 21, 2010
Thursday, December 2, 2010
Top Chef All-Stars, Episode 1
I have to credit the producers for doing at least one thing right: Making me forget at least some of the horribleness that was Top Chef: Just Desserts. For once, everything seemed to be good on this show!
But let's back up for a moment. There was the usual montage of the contestants arriving, but instead of personal background, we were reminded of some of the more interesting moments of their season. Mostly, those moments were the Judges' Table that led to their elimination, which I am sure was memorable for them but not so important for me. Then again, I don't want them dwelling on the past too much. I can only listen to Marcel talk about the head shaving incident so much.
One other note on the arriving contestants: It looks like Fabio, the chef loved by everyone, has gained a lot of weight. On the other side of things, Jamie from the same season appears to have lost a fair amount of weight. I wonder if Fabio was eating a lot of scallops after his "Top Scallop" remark from his season.
Anyway, the Quickfire was interesting in concept but lacked a bit in its execution. The 18 contestants broke up into teams based on their season and had to cook a dish that represented their host city (no, I will not list them all here). As @JeffHouck said on Twitter last night, the producers are a little late to suddenly take an interest in DC cuisine, after ignoring it for most of Season 7. The DC contestants didn't help matters by going for crab cakes, which are a MARYLAND food item, not DC. Come on! We have our own cuisine! Classic Americana is what we do (I think.)
@sjcaustenite pointed something out as well about the imbalance of the teams. Do some quick math, and you'll see that 18/7 does not divide evenly. Some teams had four people (Season 4), and others had 2 (Season 1, aka "The Season Without Padma"). I don't know if that really mattered, because the original instructions were to make one dish, and I would say that four people on one team collaborating is pretty hard. Just look at Quickfires and Elimination challenges from the past.
Long story short, Season 4 won with a Chicago hot dog with mustard gelato, courtesy of Richard Blais. As you do. Season 4 cast won immunity this episode.
Elimination Challenge: Recreate the dish that got you eliminated. I loved this challenge. All-Stars is being billed as a chance at redemption for the chefs, most of whom made it to the final four in their season. Plus, we get to relive some truly horrible dishes, like Spike's frozen scallops or the butterscotch scallops. Hm. I'm realizing that scallops don't really go over well with the judges.
Highlights from the tasting of the dishes included a throwdown between Fabio and new judge Anthony Bourdain. I am so excited to see Bourdain on the panel, because he's funny and incredibly direct when he doesn't like something. And when he hates it, he'll even toss in a random (though amusing) metaphor. The man kicks ass. So when Fabio said that he didn't appreciate the comments Bourdain made while eating his dish, Bourdain held his ground and said it sucked. Score one for Bourdain!
When we got around to Judges' Table, we all were surprised when Tom told Blais that he was in the top four as far as taste went, but because Blais went over his time (he did, and blatantly) he was disqualified from winning the round. And Tom knew this because he reviewed the tapes after the meals. Wow. We FINALLY get justice meted out immediately after a rule violation. No more pea puree incidents, I hope. After some back and forth, Angelo (boo, hiss) came out on top (that's what she said) and won 10,000 dollars to boot.
Bottom three were Stephen, Elia, and Fabio. You may remember Elia as the person who shaved her head first in the Season 2 head-shaving incident. No? Well either she or the producers do. But don't worry about her too much longer. Since her fish was not just raw on the inside, but even on the outside and she did virtually nothing to improve the food she was previously eliminated for, she got the boot. I am not that heartbroken.
Overall, I really enjoyed the episode. It's nice to see that the show is getting back on course after some prior missteps. Also, all the reminiscing by the contestants makes me want to write a drinking game, so keep an eye out for the rules, which I hope to post by episode 2.
Monday, May 3, 2010
Random thoughts about tonight's How I Met Your Mother.
I didn't get a chance to live-tweet tonight's How I Met Your Mother, but I was able to watch it later. Here, in chronological order, are some thoughts I had during the episode as I watched it. I hope it's just as entertaining as if I had live-tweeted. If you like it, please feel free to follow me regularly on Twitter at @TalkingTV
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Very nice callback to the milk argument from when Ted and Robin were friends with benefits. Which makes me wonder if the stricken look on Barney's face there is reminiscent of that.
But I will also add, that Robin cuddling and kissing the milk carton is a little disturbing.
When Don found out that they used to date, there was a nice freeze frame of reactions. Kudos to Cobie for her facial expressions there.
They slept for 18 hours straight? Wow, either they were drugged or those were some beds.
Wait, haven't we had a false assumption of Ted being gay before? Though I will say, with the sample set that Don has to work with, I can totally see how he would reach that conclusion. I mean, calligraphy instructor and ordering special ink?
Hey, that "I'm not gay if I drink appletini" joke was stolen from Scrubs!
In all this time, Marshall and Lily have never slept in different beds? What about that time when they were tying to fatten up Lily before her wedding?
Oh, Don. I know you mean well trying to bring over Barney and Ted to dinner, but that is SUCH A STUPID IDEA.
I love the overly dramatic tone Barney used just now when he said "I must have Robin back"
Apparently he didn't write that letter after he broke up with Natalie the first time or he would have remembered about breaking up with her on her birthday.
I will say that letter is a really good idea. But I do like that Barney's letter is all about boobs.
Wow, they got those new beds really fast. And now a sex bed? How can they afford all this again?
A bold but stupid move by Barney there. Never eat a random jalapeno pepper, guys.
Oh, I love milk-related continuity.
Ted is totally the kind of person who would have a box called "For My Biographer."
Drunk Ted with Drunk Barney is a recipe for AWESOMENESS.
Wait, what was Marshall thinking of about "pushing them together" if it wasn't the beds? (a minute later) Oh, wait, I got it now.
Barney moved really slow from the bathroom to the kitchen there. I was expecting a tackle or something. And where did that blue french horn come from? Didn't he give the french horn back when they broke up? How did we not see Drunk Ted stealing it back?
Aw, she moved everything out but the horn! That's depressing.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Very nice callback to the milk argument from when Ted and Robin were friends with benefits. Which makes me wonder if the stricken look on Barney's face there is reminiscent of that.
But I will also add, that Robin cuddling and kissing the milk carton is a little disturbing.
When Don found out that they used to date, there was a nice freeze frame of reactions. Kudos to Cobie for her facial expressions there.
They slept for 18 hours straight? Wow, either they were drugged or those were some beds.
Wait, haven't we had a false assumption of Ted being gay before? Though I will say, with the sample set that Don has to work with, I can totally see how he would reach that conclusion. I mean, calligraphy instructor and ordering special ink?
Hey, that "I'm not gay if I drink appletini" joke was stolen from Scrubs!
In all this time, Marshall and Lily have never slept in different beds? What about that time when they were tying to fatten up Lily before her wedding?
Oh, Don. I know you mean well trying to bring over Barney and Ted to dinner, but that is SUCH A STUPID IDEA.
I love the overly dramatic tone Barney used just now when he said "I must have Robin back"
Apparently he didn't write that letter after he broke up with Natalie the first time or he would have remembered about breaking up with her on her birthday.
I will say that letter is a really good idea. But I do like that Barney's letter is all about boobs.
Wow, they got those new beds really fast. And now a sex bed? How can they afford all this again?
A bold but stupid move by Barney there. Never eat a random jalapeno pepper, guys.
Oh, I love milk-related continuity.
Ted is totally the kind of person who would have a box called "For My Biographer."
Drunk Ted with Drunk Barney is a recipe for AWESOMENESS.
Wait, what was Marshall thinking of about "pushing them together" if it wasn't the beds? (a minute later) Oh, wait, I got it now.
Barney moved really slow from the bathroom to the kitchen there. I was expecting a tackle or something. And where did that blue french horn come from? Didn't he give the french horn back when they broke up? How did we not see Drunk Ted stealing it back?
Aw, she moved everything out but the horn! That's depressing.
Sunday, April 25, 2010
Thoughts on Amazing Race, Episode 10
So it's been a while since I actually wrote a full-length blog post about anything, but I have some time tonight so I figure I'll do it about tonight's episode of Amazing Race.
From the onset, I already knew that it was going to be a non-elimination leg just from the logic of the matter: three episodes to go, 4 teams in it, and there's no way that there's going to be a Speed Bump in the last leg. So it was more a matter of who would come in last as opposed to who would be eliminated.
Anyway, overall it was a pretty good episode. The tasks as a whole were very well designed without anything that was too simplistic. As soon as I saw the noodle making Roadblock, I immediately thought of the Detour from Amazing Race 11 (All-Stars) where they had to make a ton of Chinese noodles. This one seemed much more labor intensive and a bit harder to manage, which was nice. I particularly like how Louie decided that he was the master of pasta making because he was Italian, only to mess it up for an extensive period of time.
The next task, where they had to find the exact clothes for a model was an interesting variation on the "needle in a haystack" style of tasks. But even so, it wasn't particularly notable other than when the detectives' and Dan/Jordan's models somehow had switched leggings. And the part where the detectives completely missed the door to the task despite it being next to the clue box. Oh, and the part where the detectives made an assumption that Jordan would do well at the task because he's gay. Basically, not a lot going for the detectives at this point.
But it would be the final task, a first-time-ever second Roadblock, that would be the defining part of the leg. The racer got a picture and 96 placards and had to arrange the placards in so they mirrored the picture. Then, those placards were given to people in the stands and if the arrangement was right, when the spectators flipped their placard the racer would see where in a stadium the next clue was hidden. Pretty intricate as tasks go, and very nice designwork by the producers.
For this Roadblock, the team member who did not do the first Roadblock got to this one. It's unfortunate that Caite did not get to do this Roadblock because I would have been very amused by the eventual meltdown. Despite the best efforts of the wind to mess up Brent/Caite (and the rest of the teams) no one really encountered any difficulties with this task....except for the detectives. Despite starting ahead of Dan/Jordan they fell behind to last place and were punked by Phil at the mat before being told they were spared elimination. I don't think the detectives are destined for the final 3.
So as I said, as far as task design goes, there was a lot to like. As the racers themselves, the detectives proved their ineptitude at nearly everything, grousing that what they'd really like is a task where they have to chase a crackhead down. (And I would watch that show). If I get some time later, I'll try adding to this post some of the better quotes and my responses to them (as pulled off my Twitter feed (@TalkingTV) but for now, here's what you get.
From the onset, I already knew that it was going to be a non-elimination leg just from the logic of the matter: three episodes to go, 4 teams in it, and there's no way that there's going to be a Speed Bump in the last leg. So it was more a matter of who would come in last as opposed to who would be eliminated.
Anyway, overall it was a pretty good episode. The tasks as a whole were very well designed without anything that was too simplistic. As soon as I saw the noodle making Roadblock, I immediately thought of the Detour from Amazing Race 11 (All-Stars) where they had to make a ton of Chinese noodles. This one seemed much more labor intensive and a bit harder to manage, which was nice. I particularly like how Louie decided that he was the master of pasta making because he was Italian, only to mess it up for an extensive period of time.
The next task, where they had to find the exact clothes for a model was an interesting variation on the "needle in a haystack" style of tasks. But even so, it wasn't particularly notable other than when the detectives' and Dan/Jordan's models somehow had switched leggings. And the part where the detectives completely missed the door to the task despite it being next to the clue box. Oh, and the part where the detectives made an assumption that Jordan would do well at the task because he's gay. Basically, not a lot going for the detectives at this point.
But it would be the final task, a first-time-ever second Roadblock, that would be the defining part of the leg. The racer got a picture and 96 placards and had to arrange the placards in so they mirrored the picture. Then, those placards were given to people in the stands and if the arrangement was right, when the spectators flipped their placard the racer would see where in a stadium the next clue was hidden. Pretty intricate as tasks go, and very nice designwork by the producers.
For this Roadblock, the team member who did not do the first Roadblock got to this one. It's unfortunate that Caite did not get to do this Roadblock because I would have been very amused by the eventual meltdown. Despite the best efforts of the wind to mess up Brent/Caite (and the rest of the teams) no one really encountered any difficulties with this task....except for the detectives. Despite starting ahead of Dan/Jordan they fell behind to last place and were punked by Phil at the mat before being told they were spared elimination. I don't think the detectives are destined for the final 3.
So as I said, as far as task design goes, there was a lot to like. As the racers themselves, the detectives proved their ineptitude at nearly everything, grousing that what they'd really like is a task where they have to chase a crackhead down. (And I would watch that show). If I get some time later, I'll try adding to this post some of the better quotes and my responses to them (as pulled off my Twitter feed (@TalkingTV) but for now, here's what you get.
Monday, April 12, 2010
Future of the blog
I've had some time now to think about what I want to do with this blog, and I've come to a decision. As much as I like writing some long-form pieces about TV, I also like doing snarky commentary about what I think when I watch the show live. And in fact, I enjoy that a lot more at times than the time it takes to really put together longer 'articles'.
So, while some long-form writings may eventually work its way back onto this site, I recommend you watch my Twitter feed @TalkingTV where I'll be live-blogging (or, live-tweeting) my favorite shows as they air, such as The Amazing Race, How I Met Your Mother, and The Big Bang Theory. I may also throw in some other things like South Park, NCIS, Community, and 30 Rock once in a while.
I hope that you'll enjoy these shows as much as I do and find my running commentary at least mildly interesting.
Thanks.
So, while some long-form writings may eventually work its way back onto this site, I recommend you watch my Twitter feed @TalkingTV where I'll be live-blogging (or, live-tweeting) my favorite shows as they air, such as The Amazing Race, How I Met Your Mother, and The Big Bang Theory. I may also throw in some other things like South Park, NCIS, Community, and 30 Rock once in a while.
I hope that you'll enjoy these shows as much as I do and find my running commentary at least mildly interesting.
Thanks.
Sunday, February 14, 2010
Amazing Race 16, Episode 1: Recap and thoughts (Part 1)
Tonight was the season premiere of The Amazing Race, which as most people know is my favorite television show. I went into the episode knowing a little bit about this season's contestants, specifically that one team had the famous Miss Teen America contestant from South Carolina that couldn't formulate a response about geography (video is here) So I was very excited to see what would happen tonight.
I was not disappointed.
The episode began with the standard team introductions, none of which were all that exciting. I was rather impressed with a few teams. There was a grandmother/granddaughter team where both members are triathletes, brothers where one of them is gay and the other is straight, and a pair of rodeo riders. Beyond that, the only two teams of note were Miss Teen South Carolina (her name is Caite) and her boyfriend, and Jeff/Jordan, a c0uple who met on the last season of Big Brother. These two teams will show up quite a lot as this goes on.
So, the teams started in Los Angeles and were told that there were two flights out of LAX to Chile. The first plane only had room for three teams and the second plane took the remaining eight. As divisions go, I actually approved of this because it gave a much better incentive to rush to the airport. Unfortunately for the teams, they discovered at the starting line that they would have to get to LAX on public transit. Immediately, I was concerned that there would be many teams that would be unable to navigate the LA public transit system. Images of 20 minutes of bus changes flashed through my head.
Thankfully, the producers had placed the starting line very close to Union Station where teams had the option of taking a Metro train or a bus to the airport. As a person who takes public transit for work, I always support trains over buses because trains (generally) don't need to stop for traffic. Which is why I was stunned when the teams on the bus made it to the airport ahead of the Metro people. This is good to know in the event I ever need to find my way around Los Angeles: Take the bus, not the rail.
Here's where the first geography gaffe of the night happened. Jordan ran off the bus to the ticket counter and asked for tickets to China. Now, somehow, she was counted as one of the first three teams so she and Jeff were scheduled to go on the first flight. Personally, I think if you ask for tickets to China, you should get tickets to China. You just lost the right to ask for tickets to Chile. Step aside and let someone through who can read a five-letter name of a country. But alas, my pleas went unanswered.
Once all the teams got their tickets, much fun was had at Caite's expense, with Dan (the gay brother) reminding everyone about her mistake at the pageant. Dan actually does a very good impression of Caite. Though his voice is not quite right, his speech pattern is spot on. I'm sure we'll see some more of this as the race goes on, but I'm kind of glad to see that the show is getting most of the pageant stuff out of the way early.
Then came big mistake number two. The rodeo guys decided to exchange their money while they were still in LAX. In general, this is a smart idea because money changing takes time and you'll have to do it anyway, so why not in LAX? Unfortunately, for reasons that are a mystery to me, the duo decided to exchange their money for Brazilian rand. I believe it goes without saying that Chile does not accept the Brazilian rand.
Meanwhile, a lesbian couple were hoping for the downfall of the first flight. Specifically, one of them, whose name is Brandy. She wished for rain or mechanical failure. She got her wish: The first flight was delayed by mechanical difficulties and forced the lead three teams to switch to the same flight as the other eight. This meant that for the first time ever, all teams in the first leg were on the same flight. Only 15 minutes in and already fun things were happening.
(To be continued in Part 2)
I was not disappointed.
The episode began with the standard team introductions, none of which were all that exciting. I was rather impressed with a few teams. There was a grandmother/granddaughter team where both members are triathletes, brothers where one of them is gay and the other is straight, and a pair of rodeo riders. Beyond that, the only two teams of note were Miss Teen South Carolina (her name is Caite) and her boyfriend, and Jeff/Jordan, a c0uple who met on the last season of Big Brother. These two teams will show up quite a lot as this goes on.
So, the teams started in Los Angeles and were told that there were two flights out of LAX to Chile. The first plane only had room for three teams and the second plane took the remaining eight. As divisions go, I actually approved of this because it gave a much better incentive to rush to the airport. Unfortunately for the teams, they discovered at the starting line that they would have to get to LAX on public transit. Immediately, I was concerned that there would be many teams that would be unable to navigate the LA public transit system. Images of 20 minutes of bus changes flashed through my head.
Thankfully, the producers had placed the starting line very close to Union Station where teams had the option of taking a Metro train or a bus to the airport. As a person who takes public transit for work, I always support trains over buses because trains (generally) don't need to stop for traffic. Which is why I was stunned when the teams on the bus made it to the airport ahead of the Metro people. This is good to know in the event I ever need to find my way around Los Angeles: Take the bus, not the rail.
Here's where the first geography gaffe of the night happened. Jordan ran off the bus to the ticket counter and asked for tickets to China. Now, somehow, she was counted as one of the first three teams so she and Jeff were scheduled to go on the first flight. Personally, I think if you ask for tickets to China, you should get tickets to China. You just lost the right to ask for tickets to Chile. Step aside and let someone through who can read a five-letter name of a country. But alas, my pleas went unanswered.
Once all the teams got their tickets, much fun was had at Caite's expense, with Dan (the gay brother) reminding everyone about her mistake at the pageant. Dan actually does a very good impression of Caite. Though his voice is not quite right, his speech pattern is spot on. I'm sure we'll see some more of this as the race goes on, but I'm kind of glad to see that the show is getting most of the pageant stuff out of the way early.
Then came big mistake number two. The rodeo guys decided to exchange their money while they were still in LAX. In general, this is a smart idea because money changing takes time and you'll have to do it anyway, so why not in LAX? Unfortunately, for reasons that are a mystery to me, the duo decided to exchange their money for Brazilian rand. I believe it goes without saying that Chile does not accept the Brazilian rand.
Meanwhile, a lesbian couple were hoping for the downfall of the first flight. Specifically, one of them, whose name is Brandy. She wished for rain or mechanical failure. She got her wish: The first flight was delayed by mechanical difficulties and forced the lead three teams to switch to the same flight as the other eight. This meant that for the first time ever, all teams in the first leg were on the same flight. Only 15 minutes in and already fun things were happening.
(To be continued in Part 2)
Labels:
amazing,
amazing race,
Big Brother,
CBS,
race,
reality,
television,
the amazing race
Wednesday, March 19, 2008
Why I'm NOT Watching American Idol
t's true. I have betrayed television. I refuse to watch American Idol.
You may gasp now.
But what exactly is the appeal of American Idol? No, really, if you watch the show on a regular basis, why do you keep coming back?
Is it to watch the judges repeat their stock lines as they critique the singers? I doubt it. Any judging can be summarized as follows: Randy says, "I felt it, dawg". Paula says, "Your heart was really in it". And Simon says "Red, blue, green".
Oh, wait, that's Simon Says. The real Simon says variations of "you suck."
OK, it's not the judges. How about the singers? Why not tune in for three free concerts every week by (presumably) very talented people?
Here's my answer: Because it's not interesting. I do love listening to music, but not the stupidity of hearing old songs over and over again. I would be much more entertained if they had to write their own songs, because that would show they had more creative talent.
I'm not even going to entertain the notion that you watch this show for Ryan Seacrest. If that is in fact why you watch, I feel very sorry for you.
So what's left? The voting. By far, the primary reason people watch is so they can vote for what singer they want to keep for the next round. The idea of being a part of the decision-making process is exciting! And how can you vote if you didn't watch the show? Uninformed voting is what presidential elections are for, not future singing careers!
Please. Odds are that I'll never intentionally listen to any winner's albums afterwards, so why bother voting?
And there you have it: There's no reason for me to watch American Idol. I think I'll go watch Mythbusters instead. Now that's a real show.
You may gasp now.
But what exactly is the appeal of American Idol? No, really, if you watch the show on a regular basis, why do you keep coming back?
Is it to watch the judges repeat their stock lines as they critique the singers? I doubt it. Any judging can be summarized as follows: Randy says, "I felt it, dawg". Paula says, "Your heart was really in it". And Simon says "Red, blue, green".
Oh, wait, that's Simon Says. The real Simon says variations of "you suck."
OK, it's not the judges. How about the singers? Why not tune in for three free concerts every week by (presumably) very talented people?
Here's my answer: Because it's not interesting. I do love listening to music, but not the stupidity of hearing old songs over and over again. I would be much more entertained if they had to write their own songs, because that would show they had more creative talent.
I'm not even going to entertain the notion that you watch this show for Ryan Seacrest. If that is in fact why you watch, I feel very sorry for you.
So what's left? The voting. By far, the primary reason people watch is so they can vote for what singer they want to keep for the next round. The idea of being a part of the decision-making process is exciting! And how can you vote if you didn't watch the show? Uninformed voting is what presidential elections are for, not future singing careers!
Please. Odds are that I'll never intentionally listen to any winner's albums afterwards, so why bother voting?
And there you have it: There's no reason for me to watch American Idol. I think I'll go watch Mythbusters instead. Now that's a real show.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)