I have to credit the producers for doing at least one thing right: Making me forget at least some of the horribleness that was
Top Chef: Just Desserts. For once, everything seemed to be good on this show!
But let's back up for a moment. There was the usual montage of the contestants arriving, but instead of personal background, we were reminded of some of the more interesting moments of their season. Mostly, those moments were the Judges' Table that led to their elimination, which I am sure was memorable for them but not so important for me. Then again, I don't want them dwelling on the past too much. I can only listen to Marcel talk about the head shaving incident so much.
One other note on the arriving contestants: It looks like Fabio, the chef loved by everyone, has gained a lot of weight. On the other side of things, Jamie from the same season appears to have lost a fair amount of weight. I wonder if Fabio was eating a lot of scallops after his "Top Scallop" remark from his season.
Anyway, the Quickfire was interesting in concept but lacked a bit in its execution. The 18 contestants broke up into teams based on their season and had to cook a dish that represented their host city (no, I will not list them all here). As @JeffHouck said on Twitter last night, the producers are a little late to suddenly take an interest in DC cuisine, after ignoring it for most of Season 7. The DC contestants didn't help matters by going for crab cakes, which are a MARYLAND food item, not DC. Come on! We have our own cuisine! Classic Americana is what we do (I think.)
@sjcaustenite pointed something out as well about the imbalance of the teams. Do some quick math, and you'll see that 18/7 does not divide evenly. Some teams had four people (Season 4), and others had 2 (Season 1, aka "The Season Without Padma"). I don't know if that really mattered, because the original instructions were to make one dish, and I would say that four people on one team collaborating is pretty hard. Just look at Quickfires and Elimination challenges from the past.
Long story short, Season 4 won with a Chicago hot dog with mustard gelato, courtesy of Richard Blais. As you do. Season 4 cast won immunity this episode.
Elimination Challenge: Recreate the dish that got you eliminated. I loved this challenge. All-Stars is being billed as a chance at redemption for the chefs, most of whom made it to the final four in their season. Plus, we get to relive some truly horrible dishes, like Spike's frozen scallops or the butterscotch scallops. Hm. I'm realizing that scallops don't really go over well with the judges.
Highlights from the tasting of the dishes included a throwdown between Fabio and new judge Anthony Bourdain. I am so excited to see Bourdain on the panel, because he's funny and incredibly direct when he doesn't like something. And when he hates it, he'll even toss in a random (though amusing) metaphor. The man kicks ass. So when Fabio said that he didn't appreciate the comments Bourdain made while eating his dish, Bourdain held his ground and said it sucked. Score one for Bourdain!
When we got around to Judges' Table, we all were surprised when Tom told Blais that he was in the top four as far as taste went, but because Blais went over his time (he did, and blatantly) he was disqualified from winning the round. And Tom knew this because he reviewed the tapes after the meals. Wow. We FINALLY get justice meted out immediately after a rule violation. No more pea puree incidents, I hope. After some back and forth, Angelo (boo, hiss) came out on top (that's what she said) and won 10,000 dollars to boot.
Bottom three were Stephen, Elia, and Fabio. You may remember Elia as the person who shaved her head first in the Season 2 head-shaving incident. No? Well either she or the producers do. But don't worry about her too much longer. Since her fish was not just raw on the inside, but even on the outside and she did virtually nothing to improve the food she was previously eliminated for, she got the boot. I am not that heartbroken.
Overall, I really enjoyed the episode. It's nice to see that the show is getting back on course after some prior missteps. Also, all the reminiscing by the contestants makes me want to write a drinking game, so keep an eye out for the rules, which I hope to post by episode 2.