Wednesday, March 19, 2008

Why I'm NOT Watching American Idol

t's true. I have betrayed television. I refuse to watch American Idol.

You may gasp now.

But what exactly is the appeal of American Idol? No, really, if you watch the show on a regular basis, why do you keep coming back?

Is it to watch the judges repeat their stock lines as they critique the singers? I doubt it. Any judging can be summarized as follows: Randy says, "I felt it, dawg". Paula says, "Your heart was really in it". And Simon says "Red, blue, green".

Oh, wait, that's Simon Says. The real Simon says variations of "you suck."

OK, it's not the judges. How about the singers? Why not tune in for three free concerts every week by (presumably) very talented people?

Here's my answer: Because it's not interesting. I do love listening to music, but not the stupidity of hearing old songs over and over again. I would be much more entertained if they had to write their own songs, because that would show they had more creative talent.

I'm not even going to entertain the notion that you watch this show for Ryan Seacrest. If that is in fact why you watch, I feel very sorry for you.

So what's left? The voting. By far, the primary reason people watch is so they can vote for what singer they want to keep for the next round. The idea of being a part of the decision-making process is exciting! And how can you vote if you didn't watch the show? Uninformed voting is what presidential elections are for, not future singing careers!

Please. Odds are that I'll never intentionally listen to any winner's albums afterwards, so why bother voting?

And there you have it: There's no reason for me to watch American Idol. I think I'll go watch Mythbusters instead. Now that's a real show.

No comments: